On Monday, Microsoft Corp filed it’s first-ever lawsuit involving a case of click fraud. The civil lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for Western Washington against three individuals – Eric Lam, Gordon Lam and Melanie Suen, of Vancouver, British Columbia and companies they control. Microsoft alleges that the three engaged in massive click fraud, which impacted Microsoft’s online advertising platform and potentially other networks. Microsoft is asking for $750,000 in damages.
According to Microsoft, in Spring 2008, the three involved in a massive click fraud scheme to drive traffic to their auto insurance and the World of Warcraft websites. The click fraud scheme targeted advertisers bidding for the search terms “auto insurance” and “WoW”. So, it was a “competitor click fraud”, which is done to boost their performance of own ads by exhaust competitor’s advertising budget. The fraudsters earned thousands of dollars in profit by promoting auto insurance and virtual currency used in online role-playing game World of Warcraft.
Microsoft started internal investigation on the click fraud scheme on March 24, 2008, when it received complaints from Microsoft AdCenter advertisers. It exposed the frauds by tracing the source of the allegedly fraudulent traffic back to the computers or servers run by the defendants. Interestingly, all the three fraudsters are from the same family!In the complaint, Microsoft said that it credited nearly $1.5 million to the advertisers affected by the defendants’ actions.
Click fraud is a type of Internet crime that occurs in pay per click online advertising when a person, automated script or computer program imitates a legitimate user of a web browser clicking on an ad, for the purpose of generating a charge per click without having actual interest in the target of the ad’s link. Click fraud not only hurts the performance of the ads, but also lowers their rankings. It is a serious issue in the pay per click online advertising industry. According to ClickForensics, the overall industry average click fraud rate was 13.8% for Q1 2009, which means one in every seven click on an advertisement is fraudulent!
With this lawsuit Microsoft seeks an injunction to help stop this illegitimate activity and to recover damages. Tim Cranton, the software company’s Associate General Counsel, wrote in a blog post:
TweetThe online advertising industry has been making strides in this area for years, implementing technology, best practices and techniques to help address issues such as click fraud. Today’s action is one more step to expand that effort by utilizing the legal system to combat click fraud. Enforcement can play a critical safety role, supplementing technology and industry best practices, by using lawsuits and criminal prosecutions to stop the most egregious violators and hold them accountable for the fraud they commit.

Subscribe via RSS
Connect via Twitter



This will become a major problem for interactive marketers. It’s more than just this one case: http://domusinc.blogspot.com/2009/06/click-fraud-and-ppc-marketing.html
erk. super dangerous of click found issue..
WoWMine and the Super Continental companies were beneficially owned by David Guo (Guo Yao Qi) 郭耀琦 the whole operation has now stopped trading. Eric Lam was just the front man or proxy. He is a Canadian citizen with a Western MBA so was the only employee of the gold farmers able to set up the credit card accounts necessary for WoWMine to operate in the west. He left the business in April 2009. David Guo’s company in China was called Guangzhou UE Digital Technology Co. Ltd. David Guo realised that the gold farming business existed at the whim of Blizzard, so created his own game with the sale of in-game items built into it. This game is Evony. Just as with the gold farming he set up a USA front company, Evony LLC. To handle the money he set up Super Continental LLC. The director of both is Lu Lu, a friend of David Guo’s and another proxy. The money from the game goes to another Super Continental company, this time in Hong Kong, which is owned by yet another Super Continental company, this time in the Marshall Islands, which is tax free and has near zero corporate disclosure. The business earns over $150,00 per day. It is Google’s fifth biggest advertiser. More here: http://arstechnica.com/gaming/news/2010/03/evony-investigating-the-game-everyone-loves-to-hate.ars
David Guo is hiding from this whole Microsoft case so has moved to a new Guangzhou company with as misleading a name as possible: Qingdao Dragon Import & Export Co., Ltd,.
@Lu Lu
Really surprised that comment made it through.
Companies use holding companies to minimise tax – big shocker. Companies use pictures of women to sell products – Wow. Really? Somebody better tell the folks selling sports cars that…oh wait, never mind. Companies marketing online games are making a packet. Now that is a true revelation. I thought they did it for love.
I think the real problem with Evony is simply that they are successful and have grown rapidly. All the vested interests are scared and all the teens are annoyed that Evony actually contains no nudity whatsoever.
Jealousy is an ugly thing.
If Evony was so evil then in line with this article you would think that folks would just click the ads and try to bankrupt them. What actually happens is that folks click the ads and play and have fun.
That sounds terrible, we must end it at once.